Springs Farm: Madhuku questions legality of land withdrawal, cites Supreme Court precedents

Date:

Professor Lovemore Madhuku

By Bhekithemba Ncube

The protracted Springs Farm land dispute took another significant turn on Monday, 16 November, when it came before Justice Tshuma, with Professor Lovemore Madhuku challenging the extent of the Minister of Lands’ powers to withdraw State land without properly considering the rights of existing beneficiaries.

Justice Tshuma reserved judgment to Thursday 19 November.

At the centre of the proceedings was whether a Minister enjoys unrestricted authority to withdraw land, even where tripartite agreements, approved leases, substantial investments and established livelihoods are involved.

Appearing for the war veterans, Professor Madhuku argued that ministerial powers must be exercised within the confines of the Administrative Justice Act, which requires administrative authorities to act lawfully, reasonably and fairly, consider representations and provide reasons for decisions affecting people’s rights and interests.

Chombo judgment and the tripartite agreement

Madhuku relied on the Supreme Court’s Chombo judgment, which addressed Government’s obligations under a tripartite investment agreement and the protection of security of tenure.

At Springs Farm, the war veterans maintain that a tripartite agreement involving Government contains provisions for renewal and a disputed addendum extending to 2029. They argue that Government cannot simply disregard these contractual arrangements when withdrawing the land.

The Chombo precedent is significant because it addresses the limits of Government’s ability to cancel land arrangements where it has itself entered into binding investment agreements.

The 2022 army schools lease

Another key issue was the existence of a permit and lease to set up world class private schools issued in 2022, which the beneficiaries maintain has never been cancelled by Government.

The same lease is being relied upon by the Zimbabwe National Army (ZNA) for its proposed development at Springs Farm.

This raises questions about how Government can proceed with withdrawing and reallocating land while an approved development arrangement involving a national institution remains in existence.

Minister Anxious Masuka

Madhuku warns against abuse of ministerial powers

The Springs Farm dispute, according to the arguments advanced, illustrates the danger of giving Ministers unrestricted powers over State land.

The war veterans have occupied and developed the farm for approximately 25 years, establishing productive agricultural operations, investing in infrastructure and developing horticultural export activities.

Yet the land was withdrawn and clandestinely transferred to businessman Billy Rautenbach under the guise of converting its use from agriculture to urban development.

Of particular concern is that the property was transferred to Rautenbach on 5 June 2025, while the initial High Court hearing in the dispute was scheduled for 17 July 2025.

The chronology raises serious questions about the circumstances surrounding the transfer while the beneficiaries’ legal challenge was awaiting hearing.

The case illustrates the risk that ministerial powers could be used to withdraw land from established beneficiaries, disregard their investments and facilitate transfers to other private interests under the pretext of urban development.

Madhuku’s argument is that the Administrative Justice Act provides essential safeguards against precisely this kind of potential abuse.

Rukawo judgement and the seven-day notice controversy

Madhuku also invoked the Rukawo judgment, which addressed the unlawful withdrawal of an offer letter belonging to a farmer who had occupied and substantially developed Oldham Farm.

The High Court set aside the withdrawal after finding serious procedural and substantive shortcomings, including the failure to meaningfully consider the farmer’s representations and investments.

Of particular significance is the seven-day notice procedure previously used by the Ministry of Lands to demand representations from beneficiaries facing withdrawal of their offer letters.

The procedure was outlawed by the court in Rukawo. However, the Ministry has continued using the seven-day notice period, including against the Springs Farm beneficiaries.

This raises further questions about the Ministry’s compliance with judicial decisions and the rule of law.

The war veterans argue that the Ministry cannot continue applying a procedure already rejected by the courts while claiming to exercise its administrative powers lawfully.

The Rukawo precedent reinforces the principle that replanning cannot automatically justify dispossession without properly considering existing investments, livelihoods and representations.

Advocate Sylvester Hashiti

Minister’s defence: Hashiti relies on Mukwaira

Appearing for the Minister of Lands, Sylvester Hashiti argued that the Minister has authority to withdraw State land, including productive land occupied by war veterans.

He relied on the Supreme Court’s Mukwaira judgment and maintained that the Minister’s decision should not be set aside merely because concerns raised by the existing beneficiaries had not been addressed.

However, Mukwaira itself demonstrates the importance of administrative accountability. The Supreme Court required the Minister to provide written reasons for the withdrawal within 21 days, failing which the withdrawal would be presumed improper and stand set aside.

The judgment therefore does not establish an unrestricted power to withdraw land without procedural safeguards.

Umwinsidale Country Estate: War veterans present a US$200 million urban development vision

Perhaps one of the most significant aspects of the Springs Farm dispute is that the current occupiers have demonstrated their capacity and willingness to participate in the very urban development being cited as justification for their displacement.

Through Sovereign Spring Properties (Private) Limited, the existing beneficiaries have advanced plans for Umwinsidale Country Estate, an ambitious mixed-use urban development project estimated at approximately US$200 million, supported by investment mobilisation plans and aligned with Zimbabwe’s broader urban development and Vision 2030 objectives.

The proposed development seeks to transform Springs Farm into a modern, integrated urban settlement incorporating residential properties, luxury apartments, commercial facilities and supporting infrastructure.

More importantly, the project incorporates national-interest developments, including a proposed modern military hospital and an elite military boarding school for the Zimbabwe Defence Forces, through a proposed partnership with the Zimbabwe National Army.

This raises an important question: if urban development is the justification for withdrawing the land from the war veterans, why should the existing beneficiaries be excluded when they have themselves presented an urban development proposal with substantial investment potential and national development benefits?

The war veterans’ position is that urban development should not be used as an instrument to dispossess existing beneficiaries, particularly when those beneficiaries have demonstrated their willingness and capacity to participate in the transformation of the property.

Rather than displacing them, Government could consider facilitating their development plans, subject to the necessary planning, regulatory and investment approvals.

The proposed US$200 million investment, military hospital, military boarding school and integrated urban development represent opportunities that deserve serious consideration.

Zimbabwe should give the existing beneficiaries an opportunity to demonstrate what they can achieve. Transforming Springs Farm into an urban development should not necessarily require displacing the very people who have occupied, developed and invested in the property for a quarter of a century.

The question should move beyond who takes the land to how the property can best serve national development, protect existing rights and attract investment.

A test for the rule of law and war veterans’ land rights

The Springs Farm proceedings raise fundamental questions about the protection of land beneficiaries, the enforceability of Government agreements and the limits of ministerial authority.

Can Government disregard a tripartite agreement extending to 2029, an existing schools lease, decades of investment and established livelihoods? Can a Minister withdraw land using a seven-day notice procedure rejected by the courts and subsequently facilitate its transfer to another private beneficiary?

For the war veterans, this is not opposition to urban development. It is a demand that development and the administration of State land must respect existing legal rights.

The wider implications extend to thousands of beneficiaries who have invested in land allocated to them under Zimbabwe’s land reform programme.

Springs Farm presents an opportunity to reconcile land rights, investment, urban development and national interests. The war veterans have put forward a US$200 million development vision that includes a military hospital and boarding school. Zimbabwe should give that proposal serious consideration rather than treating the displacement of existing beneficiaries as a prerequisite for development.

The liberation struggle was fought for the empowerment and security of Zimbabweans. The administration of land acquired through that struggle must therefore be guided by justice, accountability and respect for the law.

Where are the war veterans’ leadership and ZANU PF leaders?

The Springs Farm dispute also raises questions about the role of the leadership representing war veterans and the political leadership entrusted with safeguarding the interests of liberation war veterans.

Where are leaders such as Douglas Mahiya and other war veterans’ representatives when former liberation fighters face the loss of land they have occupied, developed and invested in for decades?

Where are the ZANU PF leadership structures when beneficiaries of the liberation struggle are involved in a protracted dispute over their land rights?

The question is not merely about political solidarity. It is about institutional responsibility, representation and ensuring that the rights and welfare of war veterans are protected in practice.

The liberation struggle was not fought simply to replace one group of beneficiaries with another. Its ideals included land empowerment, economic participation and the restoration of dignity to those who fought for independence.

The Springs Farm dispute therefore deserves attention beyond the courtroom. It calls for accountability from Government institutions and those entrusted with representing the interests of war veterans.

Springs Farm is not merely a land dispute. It is a test of the limits of ministerial power, the sanctity of Government agreements, compliance with judicial decisions and whether existing beneficiaries can participate in the country’s development rather than be displaced from it.

 The mysterious compensation

To compound the situation, the allocation of Springs Farm and neighboring Stumn Farms to Rautenbach is subject to an investigation by the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission *ZACC).

Local government minister Daniel Garwe said Rautenbach was allocated the two farms as compensation for land he ostensibly lost in Harare’s Aspindale Park. However, the legal basis for that compensation has come under sustained scrutiny after the High Court ruled in the Aspindale litigation involving Rautenbach-linked companies. In a March 25, 2019 judgment, Justice Philda Muzofa ruled that Rautenbach-linked companies, Marimba Residential Properties and Marimba Industrial Properties, did not have valid legal title to the disputed Aspindale land.

The allocation of Springs and Stuhm farms raised eyebrows, resulting in a complaint being filed with ZACC. “I write on behalf of the Stuhm Residents’ Association, of which I’m secretary and also a beneficiary of Stand Number 1332. We wish to formally report what we strongly believe to be a case of high-level public sector corruption involving the illegal allocation of large tracts of public land,” wrote the association’s secretary Trevor Saruwaka in a letter dated July 17, 2025.

Circumstances around the Aspindale Park land that Rautenbach had attempted to seize are that the property was acquired by the State for housing cooperatives under the National Housing Delivery Programme. The government allocated the land to housing cooperatives, who were then surprised when Rautenbach emerged claiming he owned the land.

The cooperatives then approached the High Court, which ruled in their favour. The March 25, 2019 ruling therefore raises serious questions about the justification for compensating Rautenbach with alternative land, given the court’s findings concerning ownership of the Aspindale land.

The other bone of contention is the scale of the compensation, which has also attracted criticism. Approximately 180 hectares of urban land in Aspindale were used as the basis for allocating more than 1,080 hectares at Springs and Stuhm farms, raising questions about the valuations and methodology used to determine the compensation.

The High Court ruling therefore raised questions about the justification for compensating Rautenbach with alternative land, given the court’s findings concerning ownership of the Aspindale properties. The scale of the proposed compensation has also attracted criticism. Approximately 180 hectares of urban land in Aspindale were used as the basis for allocating more than 1,080 hectares at Springs and Stuhm farms, raising questions about the valuations and methodology used to determine the compensation.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Sanctioned Russian payments firm A7 opens in Zimbabwe amid growing financial scrutiny

By Managing Editor Russian payments company A7 has opened offices...

Finance minister proposes zero customs duty on vehicle assembly kits

By Bhekithemba Ncube Finance Minister Professor Mthuli Ncube has proposed...

Mthuli Ncube proposes cutting customs duty on electric vehicles to 10%

Business Correspondent Finance Minister Professor Mthuli Ncube has proposed reducing...

Finance minister proposes scrapping customs duty on mobile phones

Business Correspondent Government has proposed removing customs duty on cellular...