War veterans to appeal after losing Springs Farm battle at the High Court

Date:

By Bhekithemba Ncube

War veterans who have farmed Springs Farm in Goromonzi for 25 years say they will appeal to the Supreme Court after High Court Judge Justice Anita Tshuma ruled against them in their long-running fight to stop the farm being handed over as compensation to businessman Billy Rautenbach.

Speaking outside court after the judgment, the war veterans said they were “obviously not happy” with the outcome, arguing that critical facts had been left out of the ruling.

“We believe that a lot of facts that have been left out that we thought were very critical in our case,” said Joseph Macheka, a ZANU PF Central Committee member, who has a 10-year joint venture with investors. Government is a part to the tripartite agreement which ends in 2029.

Among those facts, he said, was that the area is zoned for a school and a hospital, and that the court had dismissed the veterans’ argument on the one-time venture.

“It’s unfortunate that we find ourselves in this situation considering that we are beneficiaries of the land reform,” he said. “We look at the history of Zimbabwe, where the land came from, we look at why the liberation war was waged and we look at why land reform took place.”

“After 25 years the beneficiaries have only done one thing: to [invest] in production. It can’t be that land is taken away from deserving beneficiaries and given to a private person in the form of Billy Rautenbach.”

25 Years of Investment

The applicants in the case are Joseph Macheka, Alfred Chademana, Tamo Hove Muza, Mangisai Katsande and Unico Chikomo. They are challenging the Lands Minister’s June 2024 decision to withdraw their agricultural offer letters for subdivisions of the Goromonzi farm. 

The five say they were allocated the land under the land reform programme and have since invested their lives and savings in developing it — building homes, dams, irrigation, tobacco barns and other infrastructure, and turning it into a productive farming operation.

One of the farmers, Unico Chikomo, was named the 2024 National Young Farmer Award winner, a point the veterans have repeatedly raised as proof of productivity on the farm. 

In an earlier judgment in July 2025, Justice Regis Dembure had ruled in their favour, describing the withdrawal of their offer letters as “irrational and inconsiderate” and noting that they had long occupied the land and depended on it for their livelihoods. 

That judgment was later rescinded. In a judgment dated May 21, 2026, Justice Chitapi rescinded Justice Dembure’s 2025 judgment and granted the minister additional time to submit opposing papers, reopening the case. 

The Compensation Deal at the Centre of the Case

At the heart of the dispute is a compensation deal for Rautenbach’s company, Marimba Residential Properties Limited.

According to a letter dated March 14, 2025, from Local Government Minister Daniel Garwe, the government offered Marimba Subdivision B of Springs measuring 671.7604 hectares and the remainder of Stuhm Farm measuring 412.1091 hectares as “total and final compensation” for land in Aspindale Park, Lochinvar and Salisbury Park. 

A deed dated June 5, 2025, recorded the transfer of approximately 671.6 hectares to Marimba, describing the award as compensation. 

The veterans dispute the basis for that compensation entirely.

They point to a High Court ruling on March 25, 2019, which they say declared that Marimba Residential Properties Limited was not the rightful owner of the Aspindale Park land, and that the land had been lawfully acquired by the State and allocated to housing cooperatives. 

Therefore, there was no basis for compensating Rautenbach in the first place.

In their court papers, they argue that Rautenbach is being compensated with over 1,100 hectares of prime farmland for about 180 hectares he claims to have lost in Aspindale Park— a deal they describe as grossly disproportionate. 

Government Position

The government argues that Springs Farm has been earmarked for urban development but this has been used as a cover to compensate Billy Rautenbach for land he never owned and displace bona fide beneficiaries.

The war veterans say they are not opposed to development. Through their company, Sovereign Spring Properties, they say they have their own development plans and investors, and argue they should be given the right of first refusal if the land is converted to urban use.

“We are not resisting development,” Chikomo has previously said. “The farmers are ready to take up urban development now, as they have the right of first refusal… and are settled there legally for the past 25 years”. 

“We Are Going to Appeal”

Outside court, the veterans made clear the fight is not over.

“So we are going to appeal and we hopefully we would want the Supreme Court to really look at this matter because it goes far beyond than what’s at stake,” said one war veteran.

For the families at Springs Farm, he said, the case is about more than one farm. It is about whether beneficiaries of land reform who have spent a quarter of a century building production, homes and livelihoods can have that land taken and handed to a private businessman as compensation for a claim they say the courts had already rejected.

Rtd Major Alfred Chademana commented “This is a tragic betrayal of the liberation struggle. A reversal of the land reform.”

The judgement follows Tuesday night intrusion of the farm and destruction of irrigation infrastructure at the farm which the beneficiaries claim is an act of sabotage and intimidation

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

AHF champions Zimbabwe’s health sovereignty as US funding uncertainty deepens

By Dorcas MufiriAs Zimbabwe confronts fresh uncertainty over the...

ZIFA, PSL silence triggers parliamentary petition as football integrity dispute escalates

By Tichaona KatsvamutimaZimbabwe’s football integrity controversy has taken a...

Family feud ends in tragedy as man dies in violent confrontation

By Rejoice Musvuvugwa  GOKWE-A domestic dispute turned fatal in Gokwe,...

Victoria Falls warns of legal action over fake council notices

By Mbekezeli Ncube The City of Victoria Falls has warned...