Chiwenga does not need a sex-tape brigade

Date:

The politics of Penelope Tagwira’s threats against Temba Mliswa

By Reason Wafawarova. 

Posts attributed to Penelope Tagwira have introduced an unusual new weapon into ZANU-PF succession politics: threatened intimate photographs and videos.

Tagwira reportedly warns Temba Mliswa that unless he stops attacking Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga, she will publish intimate material involving herself and Mliswa.

She also claims to possess information about people allegedly killed for ritual or political purposes, including knowledge of where their remains may be found—and alleges that Mliswa knows about these matters.

She further threatens to expose and ridicule his anatomy before the entire country.

These are extremely serious claims. They should not be consumed merely as another entertaining instalment in Zimbabwe’s factional soap opera.

Tagwira may sincerely believe that she is defending Chiwenga from Mliswa’s relentless political attacks.

But Chiwenga does not need this kind of support. No serious presidential project should require an intimate-image brigade.

THE GENERAL DOES NOT NEED TO BE DEFENDED IN CENTIMETRES:

Whatever one thinks about Mliswa’s attacks on Chiwenga—and whatever suspicions exist about whose political interests he advances—his arguments should be answered politically.

If he misrepresents Chiwenga’s speeches, quote the speeches. If he refuses to answer questions about ZANU-PF’s alleged 45% ownership of Sakunda, ask the questions again.

If he demands that Chiwenga disown Blessed Geza, ask why one political leader must account for every person who publicly supports him.

If Mliswa is advocating for Kudakwashe Tagwirei’s political advancement, analyse that position and identify its possible commercial and factional interests.

None of this requires Zimbabwe to inspect Mliswa’s private anatomy.

Presidential suitability is not measured with a ruler.

The size of a man’s genitalia neither proves nor disproves his political argument. Body-shaming is not ideological analysis. It is humiliation dressed in factional colours.

If Chiwenga’s defence is strong, it should survive without anybody opening a private gallery.

THE LAW DOES NOT RECOGNISE FACTIONAL REVENGE PORN:

Zimbabwean law criminalises the intentional online distribution of intimate images or videos of an identifiable person without consent where the purpose is humiliation or embarrassment.

The fact that an image may originally have been created consensually does not necessarily create consent for its later publication.

Consent to intimacy is not consent to national broadcasting.

Depending on the precise wording, context and intended outcome, threats to publish such material could also raise questions about cyberbullying, harassment, coercion or extortion. Those are matters for properly constituted investigators and courts—not social-media juries.

This principle applies regardless of whether one likes Temba Mliswa.

Human rights do not become optional when the potential victim is politically irritating.

Indeed, Mliswa himself has previously publicly condemned the threatened release of private sexual material in another controversy, correctly asking what anyone gains from publishing intimate images and observing that such conduct may constitute a criminal offence.

That principle does not stop being correct when the threatened images are his own.

MURDER ALLEGATIONS ARE NOT NEGOTIATING CHIPS:

The allegations concerning people supposedly killed for ritual or political purposes are considerably more serious than the threatened intimate exposure.

If Tagwira genuinely possesses credible information about killings, missing persons, human remains or people who may have participated in concealing crimes, that information should immediately be preserved and supplied through a lawyer to the police, the National Prosecuting Authority or another competent investigative institution.

She should retain original messages, photographs, locations, dates, names, metadata and any supporting witnesses.

If she fears retaliation or distrusts particular officers, she should obtain legal representation and create a documented chain showing when, where and to whom the evidence was reported.

The information should not be used conditionally: “Stop attacking Chiwenga, or I will reveal where the bodies are.”

Human remains are not factional bargaining chips. Bereaved families are not instruments for disciplining a political commentator.

If evidence of murder exists, the public interest requires its disclosure whether Mliswa praises Chiwenga, attacks him, becomes silent or joins a monastery.

Conversely, if such allegations cannot be supported, repeating them can inflict enormous reputational damage and may expose the publisher to legal consequences.

There is no responsible middle ground in which murder allegations remain suspended over somebody’s head until they improve their political behaviour.

DOES THIS MOBILISE SUPPORT FOR CHIWENGA?

No. It mobilises attention, scandal and curiosity. Those are not the same as political support.

It may even damage Chiwenga.

His opponents can use these posts to suggest that his wider support base is vindictive, lawless or prepared to deploy private humiliation against critics.

That would be unfair unless Chiwenga authorised, encouraged or adopted the threats. There is presently no established evidence that he did.

Supporters act in their own capacity. A politician cannot control every person who claims to defend him.

But responsible political leadership should establish boundaries. Chiwenga or his authorised representatives do not need to engage Tagwira personally, insult her or create another public quarrel. A simple general principle would be sufficient:

Political disagreements must be answered politically. Private sexual material should not be published without consent. Evidence of serious crime must be reported to lawful authorities.

That statement would defend institutional politics without endorsing Mliswa’s attacks.

It would also deny opponents the opportunity to attach every reckless act by a self-appointed defender to the Vice-President.

HOW FOLLOWERS SHOULD TREAT THE POSTS:

People should resist the temptation to turn threatened intimate exposure into entertainment.

Do not request the material. Do not repost it if it appears. Do not forward it into WhatsApp groups “for investigation.” Do not publish screenshots showing nudity while pretending to condemn the publication. Do not ridicule anyone’s body.

Do not treat alleged information about killings as automatically true merely because it is dramatic.

Preserve the text of relevant threats if necessary, report potentially unlawful content to the platform and allow competent authorities and lawyers to address the evidence.

Followers should also avoid directing abuse at Tagwira. Condemning a threatened act does not require humiliating, threatening or provoking the person who allegedly made the threat.

The standard must remain consistent: neither Tagwira nor Mliswa should be subjected to non-consensual sexual exposure, intimidation or unproved criminal accusations presented as fact.

THE POLITICS MUST RETURN TO POLITICS:

Zimbabwe is already confronting serious questions about CAA3, presidential succession, the influence of wealthy business interests, the independence of Parliament and the future of constitutional government.

Those questions cannot be resolved through bedroom photographs.

Mliswa must answer political criticism through evidence. Chiwenga’s supporters must defend their preferred leader through argument, organisation and constitutional principle.

Anyone possessing evidence of murder must take it to investigators.

And private intimate material must remain private unless every identifiable participant has freely consented to publication.

The succession contest is already sufficiently undignified. It does not need to become naked.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Sanctioned Russian payments firm A7 opens in Zimbabwe amid growing financial scrutiny

By Managing Editor Russian payments company A7 has opened offices...

Finance minister proposes zero customs duty on vehicle assembly kits

By Bhekithemba Ncube Finance Minister Professor Mthuli Ncube has proposed...

Mthuli Ncube proposes cutting customs duty on electric vehicles to 10%

Business Correspondent Finance Minister Professor Mthuli Ncube has proposed reducing...

Finance minister proposes scrapping customs duty on mobile phones

Business Correspondent Government has proposed removing customs duty on cellular...